Everly Mae Jones Accident: What Happened to the Wyoming Baby and Why Her Death Became a Homicide Case

Everly Mae Jones, a 9-month-old baby girl from Cheyenne, Wyoming, died on March 26, 2025, after reportedly becoming unresponsive while in the care of her mother’s boyfriend, John D. Haney. What initially appeared to be a sudden medical emergency later became a homicide investigation after forensic findings identified asphyxiation as the cause of death. Nearly a year later, Haney was arrested and charged with first-degree murder and aggravated child abuse. He pleaded not guilty in April 2026.

What Happened?

On March 26, 2025, emergency responders were dispatched to a residence in Cheyenne following a report that Everly was not breathing.

According to investigators, John D. Haney, who was dating Everly’s mother, Sara Sharpe, reported finding the baby unresponsive during a nap.

Emergency personnel attempted to provide medical assistance, and Everly was transported to Cheyenne Regional Medical Center.

Despite efforts to save her, she was pronounced dead shortly after arriving at the hospital.

The circumstances surrounding her death were initially unclear, prompting authorities to investigate what had happened inside the home.

Cause of Death

The investigation took a significant turn when medical evidence indicated that Everly’s death was not accidental.

According to reporting on the case, forensic findings completed in December 2025 identified asphyxiation as the cause of death, and the death was classified as a homicide.

Asphyxiation occurs when the body is deprived of sufficient oxygen. In Everly’s case, the medical findings led investigators to examine whether another person’s actions had caused her death.

The homicide determination changed the direction of the investigation, shifting attention from an unexplained infant death toward possible criminal responsibility.

A medical classification of homicide, however, does not by itself establish who caused the death.

Earlier Injuries

Investigators also reported discovering evidence of injuries that appeared to have occurred before Everly’s death.

Post-mortem X-rays revealed healing fractures involving one arm and both legs.

Medical assessments reportedly placed the injuries approximately two to three weeks before her death.

Authorities described the fractures as non-accidental, raising concerns that Everly may have experienced physical abuse before the fatal incident.

These findings became an important part of the investigation because they suggested the possibility of earlier harm rather than a single unexplained emergency.

The prosecution’s allegations concerning these injuries remain subject to the legal process.

Camera Evidence

Digital evidence reportedly played a significant role in reconstructing events inside the residence.

According to court documents described by news outlets, a home security recording captured a child’s scream approximately 30 minutes before the emergency call.

Investigators also examined motion-activated camera recordings from the property.

Reports stated that two video clips recorded on the day of Everly’s death had been deleted.

The recordings and missing footage became part of the evidence reviewed by authorities.

Investigators considered their timing and possible relevance to the period before Everly was found unresponsive.

However, the existence of deleted recordings alone does not establish what happened or prove an individual’s guilt.

Arrest and Charges

After an investigation lasting almost one year, the Laramie County Sheriff’s Office announced an arrest.

John D. Haney, then 41, was arrested on March 20, 2026, in connection with Everly’s death.

He faced two serious criminal charges: first-degree murder and aggravated child abuse.

The arrest followed months of forensic examination, witness interviews and review of evidence connected to the incident.

Authorities alleged that Haney was responsible for the child’s death and earlier injuries.

The charges represented a major development for Everly’s family, who had been waiting for answers since March 2025.

Court Proceedings

Following his arrest, Haney appeared in court to respond to the allegations.

In April 2026, he pleaded not guilty in Laramie County District Court.

He was subsequently held under cash-bond conditions while awaiting further proceedings, according to published reports.

A not-guilty plea means the allegations remain contested, and prosecutors must establish the charges through the judicial process.

The medical findings, security footage and other investigative materials may be considered during court proceedings, subject to evidentiary rules.

Haney has not been established as guilty by the information presented here, and any final determination of criminal responsibility belongs to the court.

Everly’s Mother

Everly’s mother, Sara Sharpe, experienced the loss of her daughter when the baby was only nine months old.

Following Everly’s death, Sharpe began sharing her family’s experience and working to help other parents facing the loss of a child.

Her efforts developed into a charitable initiative dedicated to supporting grieving families.

Rather than allowing Everly’s memory to be defined solely by the criminal investigation, Sharpe has focused on providing comfort to people experiencing similar tragedies.

Her advocacy has become an important part of Everly’s continuing legacy.

Everly’s Foundation

Everly’s Embrace Foundation was established in memory of Everly Mae Jones.

The organization supports families affected by pregnancy and infant loss through practical assistance and remembrance initiatives.

Its activities include distributing hospital care packages, providing bereavement resources and sending handmade crocheted bunnies to grieving families.

These gifts are intended to offer comfort during an extremely difficult period.

The foundation’s work extends beyond Wyoming, reaching families in other locations.

Through this initiative, Everly’s name continues to be associated with compassion, remembrance and support for bereaved parents.

Latest Case Status

As of the information available for November 2026, the confirmed legal developments include Haney’s March 2026 arrest and his April 2026 not-guilty plea.

A final trial outcome has not been established by the reporting cited here.

The distinction between the medical finding and the criminal case remains important: Everly’s death was classified as a homicide, but the charges against Haney require a judicial determination.

The case continues to draw attention because of the child’s age, the reported earlier injuries and the evidence gathered during the investigation.

Remembering Everly

Everly Mae Jones died on March 26, 2025, at just nine months old. Her death, initially reported as an unexplained emergency, became the subject of a homicide investigation after medical findings revealed asphyxiation and earlier injuries.

While the criminal proceedings seek to determine legal responsibility, her mother has created a lasting tribute through Everly’s Embrace Foundation.

Everly’s story is now remembered both through the search for answers surrounding her death and through the support offered to grieving families in her name.

Author

  • Robin

    Robin is a dedicated author at I Want that Design, passionate about creating informative, engaging, and well-researched content. With a strong focus on quality and accuracy, Robin writes on a wide range of topics, delivering articles that educate, inspire, and provide value to readers. Committed to clear communication and credible information, Robin strives to make complex subjects easy to understand while maintaining the highest editorial standards. Through every publication, Robin aims to inform, empower, and connect with a diverse global audience.

Leave a Comment